Beyond Brew vs Ryze Coffee

Beyond Brew vs Ryze: Which Mushroom Coffee is Actually Better?

Tired of caffeine crashes and looking for a clean, energizing coffee alternative? You’ve probably come across Beyond Brew and Ryze, two of the most popular mushroom coffee brands in 2025.

But with so much hype, how do you choose?

Here’s the truth: I tested both Beyond Brew and Ryze for 2 months, and in this comparison, I’ll break down the real differences: Taste, ingredients, effects, pricing, and more, so you can decide which one fits your routine best.

Quick Verdict: Beyond Brew vs Ryze Coffee

1. Ingredients Breakdown

Beyond Brew:

• 7 Mushrooms: Lion’s Mane, Turkey Tail, Reishi, Shiitake, Cordyceps, King Trumpet, Chaga
• Chai Spices: Ginger, cinnamon, cardamom, black pepper
• Extras: Prebiotics (acacia fiber), ashwagandha, turmeric

👉 No caffeine, no coffee, more of a functional tonic than a coffee replacement.

Ryze:

• 6 Mushrooms: Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga, Shiitake, Turkey Tail

• Organic Arabica Coffee

• MCT Oil Powder

👉 Feels like real coffee, earthy taste with added focus from Lion’s Mane and Cordyceps.

2. Taste Test: What They Actually Taste Like

Beyond Brew:

• Tastes like a cozy chai hot chocolate

• Hints of cacao and spice

• Not bitter, easy to sip, even black

Ryze:

• Tastes like mild coffee with a mushroom undertone

• Earthy, a bit savory

• Some people add milk or sweetener to balance it out

🧠 My take: Beyond Brew tastes better out of the box. Ryze wins for coffee lovers.

3. Energy & Focus Effects

Beyond Brew:

• No caffeine, more of a “calm clarity”

• Great for people with anxiety, gut issues, or caffeine sensitivity

• Takes a few days to feel the mushroom effects

Ryze:

• Low caffeine kick (~½ cup of coffee)

• Noticeable mental focus from Lion’s Mane + Cordyceps

• Better for busy mornings or midday slumps

⚡ If you want a real energy boost, Ryze delivers more punch. If you want calm wellness, Beyond Brew wins.

4. Price & Value

💡 Ryze is cheaper, but Beyond Brew offers more complex ingredients per serving. Depends on what you value more: caffeine kick or total wellness.

5. Quality of Ingredients: Which Brand Uses Better Sourcing?

When it comes to functional mushrooms, not all ingredients are created equal. The quality depends on how the mushrooms are grown, what part is used, and how they're processed.

Here’s how Beyond Brew and Ryze stack up:

🍄 Beyond Brew:

• Uses whole fruiting body mushrooms, not mycelium on grain

• Sourced from organic growers, according to the brand

• Includes a wide range of functional herbs and adaptogens like ashwagandha, turmeric, and prebiotics

• Lab-tested for heavy metals and purity (according to their website)

➡️ Beyond Brew is positioned more as a total wellness product with clean sourcing, and it shows in the taste and effects.

☕ Ryze:

• Contains 6 mushrooms, but does not clearly specify if it's 100% fruiting body or includes mycelium

• Includes organic coffee and MCT oil powder

• Taste suggests real mushroom presence, but third-party testing isn’t clearly provided on the product page. Kind of a red flag on quality if you ask me, but hundreds of thousands of customers still enjoy it and report benefits.

• Prioritizes convenience and taste over full-spectrum wellness. Still good for budget buyers.

➡️ Ryze keeps it simple, but lacks some transparency in sourcing details compared to other premium brands.

Final Word on Quality:

If ingredient sourcing and full-spectrum wellness are your top priorities, Beyond Brew wins here. But if you're just trying mushroom coffee for the first time and want a smooth intro, Ryze still offers a quality, accessible option, just with fewer extras.

6. Who Should Pick Which?

Pick Beyond Brew if:

• You’re quitting caffeine or already drink decaf

• You want potential gut and immune support with your morning drink

• You love cacao or chai flavors

• You need something calming, not stimulating

Pick Ryze if:

• You want a healthier coffee that still gives you a boost

• You like simple routines, scoop, stir, done

• You’re trying mushroom coffee for the first time

• You're on a budget

Ryze vs Beyond Brew Final Take

Both Beyond Brew and Ryze are great, but they serve different needs.

I personally keep both around:

• Beyond Brew for nighttime wind-down or stress-heavy days.

• Ryze for a focused, energetic morning without the jitters.

If you want a clean energy boost and love coffee, Ryze is your best bet.
If you're looking to upgrade your wellness routine and ditch caffeine, go with Beyond Brew.

---

🛒 Try Them for Yourself

Looking to give functional coffee a shot? Both of these brands offer great starting points.

These two coffees absolutely deliver what they promise, whether that’s calm focus without caffeine (Beyond Brew) or a smoother energy boost (Ryze). For their price and convenience, they’re some of the best in the mushroom coffee space.

🧠 Want Deeper Benefits from Mushrooms?

While Beyond Brew and Ryze are great for daily routines, priced great, and have thousands of happy customers that confirm it's legit, they’re not the most potent or purely sourced mushroom products out there. Most casual mushroom coffees use blends that are functional, but often don’t use high-potency fruiting bodies or include detailed lab testing for things like beta-glucans or purity.

If you're serious about experiencing the real power of mushrooms for cognition, immunity, or long-term wellness, it's worth learning how to spot:

• Fruiting body vs. mycelium on grain

• Real beta-glucan percentages

• Transparent COAs and sourcing practices

• What high-potency extracts actually look like

👉 Start here: Fungi Purity and Potency Guide

This guide breaks it all down, so whether you’re a beginner or ready to level up, you’ll know what to look for before spending money on any mushroom supplement.

Thanks for reading! If you have any questions or suggestions on mushrooms or reviews please reach out!